Pies (44)

Fresh Bake Shop Tart - Lemon Meringue, 6 oz, $7.99

Baked Fresh in Store

Store Baked Pumpkin Pie, $4.99

Pumpkins from the Amish farmlands of Pennsylvania make this dish a must. The blend of pumpkin and spices will add to that warm Holiday feel.

Two-Bite Original Pumpkin Tarts, 16 oz, $7.99

Two-Bite Original Pumpkin Tarts, 16 oz

Store Baked Sweet Potato Pie, $4.99

100% Natural Sweet Potato complimented with a blend of spices. This pie is the perfect addition to your dessert table.

Store Baked Double Crust Lemon Pie, $7.99

Our beloved Lemon pie offers that sweet/sour flavor and brings the summer feel to your year round table.

Store Baked Dutch Apple Pie, $7.99

made with NY Apples topped with Cinnamon Sugar crunch in a flaky crust

Key Lime Meringue Pie, $6.99

Key Lime Meringue Pie

Store Baked Half Apple Pie, $4.49

Our signature recipe made with NY state Apples. Enrobed in a tender, flaky crust that is the perfect carrier for a large scoop of ice cream or the chilled fruit of choice. Additional satisfaction is achieved when served warm

Store Baked Half Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, $4.49

Sweet Ripe Strawberries mingled with a Sour taste of Rhubarb in our flakey crust.

Gourmet Apple Lattice Pie, $12.99

Crisp spiced apples nestled under a beautiful lattice crust.

Gourmet Apple Walnut Lattice Pie, $12.99

Juicy apples from Michigan topped with decadent caramel sauce and walnuts studded throughout for a hint of crunch.

Gourmet Peach Praline Lattice Pie, $12.99

Sweet, juicy freestone peaches from California are combined with the perfect amount of sweetness and praline for incredible depth of flavor.

Gourmet Very Berry Lattice Pie, $12.99

A combination of your favorite berries mixed to make a perfectly balanced filling of tart and sweet.

Fresh Bake Shop Mini Crumb Cakes, 2 ct., 6 oz, $1.99

Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 2

Banana Crème Pie, $9.99

Banana Crème Pie

Chocolate Crème Pie, $9.99

Chocolate Crème Pie

Coconut Crème Pie, $9.99

Coconut Crème Pie

Store Baked Family Size Apple Pie, $9.99

A true traditional apple pie made with its own natural juices and created with NY State Apples and just the right blend of cinnamon and spice.

Strawberry Crème Pie, $9.99

Strawberry Crème Pie

Lemon Meringue Pie, $6.99

Lemon Meringue Pie

Store Baked Pecan Pie, $8.99

Texas Roasted Pecans topped on our Sweet and buttery pie topped with a nutty aftertaste.

Table Talk Baked Apple Pie - 8 in., 24 oz, $8.99

Table Talk Baked Apple Pie - 8 in., 24 oz

Table Talk Baked Blueberry Pie - No Salt Added, 8 in., 24 oz, $8.99

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Coconut Custard, 8 Inch, 22 oz, $7.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

Fresh Bake Shop Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, 26 oz, $7.99

Sweet Ripe Strawberries mingled with a Sour taste of Rhubarb in our flakey crust.

Store Baked Cling Peach Pie, $7.99

Vine Ripened Cling Peaches perfectly balanced with cane sugar, combined in our delicious crust and baked to flaky perfection in our own stores.

Store Baked Lemon Blueberry Pie, $6.99

Our Lemon Blueberry pie offers the perfect combination of sweet and sour to add a uniquely fun flavor to any gathering.

Fresh Bake Shop Lemon Meringue Pie, 24 oz, $6.99

Lemon Meringue Pie

Chocolate Meringue Pie, $6.99

Chocolate Meringue Pie

Store Baked Cherry Pie, $7.99

Tart Michigan Cherries in our traditional flakey crust offers that warm sweet flavor for any season.