Pies (21)

Store Baked Pumpkin Pie, $4.99

Pumpkins from the Amish farmlands of Pennsylvania make this dish a must. The blend of pumpkin and spices will add to that warm Holiday feel.

Store Baked Blueberry Pie, $7.49

Our Sweet North American wild blueberries in our traditional crust offers a great year round option for your average pie lover.

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Coconut Custard, 8 Inch, 22 oz, $4.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

Store Baked Sweet Potato Pie, $4.99

100% Natural Sweet Potato complimented with a blend of spices. This pie is the perfect addition to your dessert table.

Store Baked Half Blueberry Pie, $3.99

Our Sweet North American wild blueberries in our traditional crust offers a great year round option for your average pie lover.

Fresh Bake Family Size Coconut Custard Pie, 34 oz, $8.99

10 Inch Coconut Custard Pie

Store Baked Family Size Coconut Custard Pie, $8.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Chocolate Cream Pie, 7 oz, $4.49

Graham Crumb Bottom with Chocolate Cream Filling, Finished with Creamy Whipped Topping and Shaved Chocolate.

4 Pack Hand Held Apple Lattice Pies, $3.99

A flaky and delicious blend of pie dough and puff pastry dough, filled with fruit, these hand held lattice pies are perfect for snacking, dessert or breakfast.

Store Baked Cherry Pie, $6.99

Tart Michigan Cherries in our traditional flakey crust offers that warm sweet flavor for any season.

Store Baked Family Size Apple Pie, $8.99

A true traditional apple pie made with its own natural juices and created with NY State Apples and just the right blend of cinnamon and spice.

Store Baked Family Size Pumpkin Pie, $8.99

A true home-style favorite. This pie is packed full of pumpkin and a blend of spices that will have you asking for more.   This holiday pie is sure to make any meal extra special

Lemon Meringue Pie, $6.99

Lemon Meringue Pie

Store Baked Cling Peach Pie, $6.99

Vine Ripened Cling Peaches perfectly balanced with cane sugar, combined in our delicious crust and baked to flaky perfection in our own stores.

Store Baked Dutch Apple Pie, $6.99

made with NY Apples topped with Cinnamon Sugar crunch in a flaky crust

Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Coconut Cream Pie, 7 oz, $4.49

Graham Crumb Bottom with Coconut Cream Filling, Finished with Creamy Whipped Topping and Toasted Coconut.nnToo Good to Share

Store Baked Half Apple Pie, $3.99

Our signature recipe made with NY state Apples. Enrobed in a tender, flaky crust that is the perfect carrier for a large scoop of ice cream or the chilled fruit of choice. Additional satisfaction is achieved when served warm

Store Baked Half Cherry Pie, $3.99

Tart Michigan Cherries in our traditional flakey crust offers that warm sweet flavor for any season.

Store Baked Half Cling Peach Pie, $3.99

Vine Ripened Cling Peaches perfectly balanced with cane sugar, combined in our delicious crust and baked to flaky perfection in our own stores.

Store Baked Half Coconut Custard Pie, $3.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

Store Baked Half Dutch Apple Pie, $3.99

made with NY Apples topped with Cinnamon Sugar crunch in a flaky crust