Freshly Baked (302)

Fresh Bake Shop Assorted Donuts, 1 each, $0.99

sweetened golden brown donut

Hand Dipped Strawberries, 1 Each, $13.99 avg/ea

Perfectly ripe and sweet strawberries coated in rich chocolate

Puffin Muffin, $1.99

Puffin Muffin

20 Pack Chocolate Chip Cookies, $3.99

A soft buttery flavored classic recipe full of semi sweet chocolate chips, one bite will leave you satisfied!

Chocolate Heart Shaped Cake, $14.99

Festive, delicious, and perfect for parties, our moist, delicious decorated cakes are the perfect way to complete your holiday

Store Baked Pumpkin Pie, $4.99

Pumpkins from the Amish farmlands of Pennsylvania make this dish a must. The blend of pumpkin and spices will add to that warm Holiday feel.

Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Chocolate Cream Pie, 7 oz, $3.99

Graham Crumb Bottom with Chocolate Cream Filling, Finished with Creamy Whipped Topping and Shaved Chocolate.

Superior on Main Black & White Iced Cake Cookies, 10 count, 8 oz, $5.99

Superior on Main Black & White Iced Cake Cookies, 10 count, 8 oz

Café Valley Bakery Chocolate Chip Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz, $5.49

Café Valley Bakery Chocolate Chip Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz

Fresh Bake Shop Sinfully Your's Pumpkin Pudding Cake, 18 oz, $4.00

Moist Vanilla Cake Flavored with Pumpkin & Pumpkin Pie Spice - Baked Fresh in Store

Sinfully Your's Chocolate Pudding Cake, $4.00

Moist and delicioius cake for any occasion!

6 Pack Corn Muffin Tops, $5.99

Sweet Classic Home Style Corn Muffin Top

Cheese Coffee Ring, $5.99

Enjoy our store-baked artisan coffee cake, made with dansh dough and filled with creamy cheese

Fresh Bake Shop Blueberry Muffin Tops, 15 oz, $5.99

Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 6

Inspired by Happiness Dreamin' of Chocolate Dark & White Chocolate Layer Cake, 16 oz, $15.99

Inspired by Happiness Dreamin' of Chocolate Dark & White Chocolate Layer Cake, 16 oz Delicious, Melt in Your Mouth Chocolate Cake with Layers of the Finest Belgian White Chocolate Mousse. Topped with Decadent Chocolate Ganache.

Store Baked Dutch Apple Pie, $4.99

made with NY Apples topped with Cinnamon Sugar crunch in a flaky crust

Bowl & Basket Variety Sampler Cheesecake, 16 oz, $8.99

New York Style, Chocolate Marble, Strawberry Swirl & Mississippi Mud

Sinfully Your's Raspberry Rage Pudding Cake, $4.00

Moist and delicioius cake for any occasion!

Store Made Medium Fruit Tart (5 Inch), $13.79

Shortbread crust filled with vanilla pastry cream topped with Fresh Fruit

Mini Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing, 6 Pack, $5.99

This wonderful dessert will make a great addition to your table all year round.

12 Pack Chocolate Chip Cookies, $3.49

A soft buttery flavored classic recipe full of semi sweet chocolate chips, one bite will leave you satisfied!

Fresh Baked Donuts - Apple Cider Cake, 6 Count, 12 oz, $4.99

Fresh Baked Donuts - Apple Cider Cake, 6 Count, 12 oz

24 Pack Cupcakes With Rainbow Sprinkles, $19.99

Our moist and delicious cupcakes and iced and topped with classic rainbow sprinkles

Bowl & Basket Variety Sampler Cheesecake, 40 oz, $19.99

New York Style, Strawberry Swirl, Mississippi Mud, Chocolate Marble, Raspberry Swirl, Turtle

5 Inch Strawberry Layer Shortcake, $10.99

a classic...yellow cake filled with strawberry filling, topped with sweet vanilla whipped icing and garnished with fresh strawberries

Strawberry Shortcake, $10.99

moist yellow cake layers with strawberry filling and light whipped topping

Fresh Bake Shop Mini Lemon Snail Danish, 8 oz, $5.99

A light,rich, flaky pastry filled with fruits, nuts, or cheese.

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Coconut Custard, 8 Inch, 22 oz, $4.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

Maple Donuts Pumpkin Cake Donuts, 10 oz, $4.99

Maple Donuts Pumpkin Cake Donuts, 10 oz

Store Baked Sweet Potato Pie, $4.99

100% Natural Sweet Potato complimented with a blend of spices. This pie is the perfect addition to your dessert table.