Freshly Baked (238)

Hand Dipped Strawberries, 1 Each, $19.99 avg/ea

Perfectly ripe and sweet strawberries coated in rich chocolate

Fresh Baked Donuts - Apple Cider Cake, 6 Count, 12 oz, $4.99

Fresh Baked Donuts - Apple Cider Cake, 6 Count, 12 oz

Fresh Bake Shop Assorted Donuts, 1 each, $1.39

sweetened golden brown donut

Yellow Heart Shaped Cake, $14.99

Festive, delicious, and perfect for parties, our moist, delicious decorated cakes are the perfect way to complete your holiday

20 Pack Chocolate Chip Cookies, $3.99

A soft buttery flavored classic recipe full of semi sweet chocolate chips, one bite will leave you satisfied!

20 Pack Variety Cookies, $3.99

20 Pack Variety Cookies

4 Pack Cherry Turnovers, $5.49

Flaky puff pastry dough, filled with tart cherries, our turnover is a classic breakfast, dessert or snack item.

Store Baked Pumpkin Pie, $6.99

Pumpkins from the Amish farmlands of Pennsylvania make this dish a must. The blend of pumpkin and spices will add to that warm Holiday feel.

Puffin Muffin, $2.49

Puffin Muffin

4 Pack Hand Held Cherry Lattice Pies, $2.99

A flaky and delicious blend of pie dough and puff pastry dough, filled with fruit, these hand held lattice pies are perfect for snacking, dessert or breakfast.

Mini Carrot Cake, 6 Pack, $3.99

This wonderful dessert will make a great addition to your table all year round.

4 Pack Hand Held Mixed Berry Lattice Pies, $2.99

A flaky and delicious blend of pie dough and puff pastry dough, filled with fruit, these hand held lattice pies are perfect for snacking, dessert or breakfast.

Maple Donuts Pumpkin Cake Donuts, 10 oz, $5.94

Maple Donuts Pumpkin Cake Donuts, 10 oz

24 Pack Gourmet Variety Pack Cookies, $9.99

Our Gourmet variety pack including classic White Macadamia Nut, Chocolate Chunk, and Oatmeal Raisin-the best of all variety packs

Maple Donuts Glazed Donuts, 12 count, 24 oz, $5.99

Maple Donuts Glazed Donuts, 12 count, 24 oz

1/4 Sheet Marble Cake with Vanilla Icing, $29.99

the best of both worlds. moist, light chocolate and yellow cake, finished with sweet vanilla icing

24 Pack Holiday Cupcake Pull-A-Parts, $29.99

Our talented cake decorators creativity, showcased in the form of a delicious dessert. A festive way to enjoy our delicious store decorated cupcakes

1/2 Sheet Chocolate Layer with Vanilla Icing, $46.99

the best of both worlds. moist, light chocolate cake, finished with sweet vanilla icing

Fresh Baked 1/2 Sheet Cake, Yellow Layer with Vanilla Icing, $46.99

yellow cake with a light, moist texture and sweet flavor with creamy vanilla icing

Fresh Bake Shop Fudge Iced Brownies, 8 Pack, 15 oz, $4.99

Fresh Baked Donuts - Pumpkin Cake 6 Pack, 12 oz, $4.99

Fresh Baked Donuts - Pumpkin Cake 6 Pack, 12 oz

Chocolate Heart Shaped Cake, $14.99

Festive, delicious, and perfect for parties, our moist, delicious decorated cakes are the perfect way to complete your holiday

24 Pack Cupcakes With Rainbow Sprinkles, $21.99

Our moist and delicious cupcakes and iced and topped with classic rainbow sprinkles

12 Pack Yellow & Chocolate Cupcakes With Vanilla Icing, $10.99

Something for everyone - moist and delicioius yellow and chocolate cupcakes, topped with creamy vanilla icing

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Coconut Custard, 8 Inch, 22 oz, $6.99

Our rich custard filled pie topped with our baked Toasted Coconut in a flaky Crust

6 Pack Corn Muffin Tops, $5.99

Sweet Classic Home Style Corn Muffin Top

Mini Cherry Snail Danish, 6 Pack, $4.99

A light,rich, flaky pastry filled with fruits, nuts, or cheese.

Junior's Original New York Cheesecake, 1.5 lbs, $18.99

Junior's Original New York Cheesecake, 1.5 lbs 6” Original Cheesecake The World's Most Fabulous Cheesecake™ Voted no. 1 New York Cheesecake - The best cheesecake in New York - New York Magazine

20 Pack Candy Cookies, $3.99

A sweet buttery sugar cookie loaded with colorful chocolate candies- tasty for everyday cravings!

Orejas (Elephant Ears), $4.99

Sweet Puff Pastry filled with cinnamon sugar.